Using Behavioral Science to Influence Change in Your Business
Most change initiatives fail not because the strategy is wrong, but because people do not respond the way leaders expect. Columbia Business School’s Steve Martin discusses how behavioral science helps organizations influence behavior, capture attention, and design change strategies that actually stick.
Overview
In this webinar recording, Steve Martin, academic director in Executive Education, explores how behavioral science serves as the essential third leg of a stool for driving change, complementing the traditional legs of information and incentives. While many business problems are people problems, simply providing more data or rewards often fails because it ignores how the human brain actually processes those inputs. Through models of fast and slow thinking and the identification of three universal motivations—accuracy, connection, and ego—Martin demonstrates how small, ethical interventions can solve complex challenges ranging from driver safety to debt repayment.
Key Takeaways
- The Necessity of the Third Leg: Effective influence requires moving beyond just informing or incentivizing. You must understand the psychological mechanisms behind how people react to information to create robust, sustainable change.
- Fast Thinking First: Human brains have two processing systems: System 1 (fast, automatic, reflexive) and System 2 (slow, logical, effortful). To influence stakeholders, you must first capture the attention of the fast brain before providing the rational justification for the slow brain.
- Three Universal Engines of Change: Most human behavior is driven by the need for Accuracy (making efficient decisions), Connection (gaining social approval), and Ego (maintaining a positive self-image).
- The Power of Small Switches: Minor adjustments can yield massive results. For example, moving an incentive from monthly to weekly or reframing a gain as a potential loss significantly increased safe driving compliance among bus drivers.
- Behavior Changes Mindset, Not Just Vice Versa: It is a misconception that you must change someone's mind before their behavior changes. Often, changing the behavior first—by capturing attention and making the action easy—will cause the individual's beliefs to eventually align with their new actions.
Q&A
How do cultural differences impact the application of behavioral science?
The core motivations (accuracy, connection, ego) are universal characteristics of the human condition rather than cultural ones. However, the application differs: Southern and Eastern cultures often trend toward collectivism (primed for connection triggers), while Northern and Western cultures may be more individualistic (primed for ego triggers).
How should I use fast and slow thinking to influence stakeholders?
You should always lead with fast thinking first. Because attention is the currency of influence, you must use attention-capturing strategies—like a mystery or a surprising piece of research—to engage System 1 before providing the rational evidence required by System 2.
Does behavioral science apply differently to B2B versus B2C environments?
Yes. B2C focuses on individual identities, whereas B2B focuses on entities where decisions are often spread across multiple departments. Strategies like social proof (e.g., everyone else is paying their taxes) are highly effective for individuals but often fail when applied to a business entity where no single person feels responsible for the collective behavior.
Why is behavioral science becoming more important in the modern world?
In a VUCA (Volatile, Uncertain, Complex, Ambiguous) world, people are overwhelmed by a large number of daily messages. Because of this information overload, people are actually using less and less information to make major life decisions, relying instead on quick behavioral cues and proxies like messengers.
What is the first thing a leader should do tomorrow to implement these ideas?
The most important step is to pause. Before launching a new policy or incentive, slow down and ask: "How can I align this with a fundamental human motivation—accuracy, connection, or ego—so it goes with the grain of how people naturally behave?"
Related Program
$8,400
Sign Up for Email Alerts
Sign up for program updates and content relevant to today's business leaders from Columbia Business School Executive Education.
